1

Topic: Obama's Health Care

Good Idea? Bad Idea?

[Assistant Instructor/Operations Director for Gracie Barra TX]

2

Re: Obama's Health Care

Hahaha..  What a troll!

Everything big govt touches goes to hell, what makes us think this will be anything other than a enormous failure?

3

Re: Obama's Health Care

Administrator wrote:

Hahaha..  What a troll!

Everything big govt touches goes to hell, what makes us think this will be anything other than a enormous failure?

Oh I KNOW it will be a failure. My only question is why then. If it is so obviously dumb..then why do it. Whats to gain and who's to gain it? I read an article about Brock Lesnar, who loves Canada, say he had to fly back to America to get fix after trying a few Canadian doctors first. And he said, although its far from perfect..we had the best medical doctors in the world.

[Assistant Instructor/Operations Director for Gracie Barra TX]

4

Re: Obama's Health Care

Did Brock go to a private doctor in Canada first of was it public healthcare? If it was public healthcare there is no wonder it was worse than the expensive specialist he got when he came back to the US. Public healthcare just won't ever be able to compete with a private doctor with near endless resources. I expect Brock would not be happy with the work of the average american doctor either. Not saying they aren't good, they just don't have the resources. No doctor working for the average person does.

5

Re: Obama's Health Care

Oh and I think the healthcare thing is a good idea and long overdue. Isn't the whole idea behind the reform to bring healthcare to the poor citizen? How can that be a bad thing? If youre rich you can still pay for a private doctor. Of course there might be some bugs in the system but that is inevitable with any big reform.

6

Re: Obama's Health Care

very good decision from president obama; here in europe we have an health care system from decades ago; in my humble opinion health care and education , SHOULD be equal for everyone, whatever you are rich or poor.

7

Re: Obama's Health Care

Johan and Amando, two people who don't understand whatexactly this mean health care means.

http://www.thebjjlifestyle.com/

8

Re: Obama's Health Care

it would be nice to hear your explanation shawn about healthcare; maybe we can understand better after hearing your explanation...

9

Re: Obama's Health Care

Yes. Please explain.

10

Re: Obama's Health Care

Don't get me wrong, i think people should be be taken care of medically. I don't think Health ins. should be forced upon you and that is exactly what will happen. 1. If you choose not to have the ins. you are fined. (could be in form of a tax) 2. Taxes WILL go up, for EVERYONE. 3.Rich people or not so rich, but people who make good money (i.e. middle class) should NOT have to pay for everyone else. 4. The United States is not a socialist country and this is a socialist program. 5. There are other ways to improve the system. (i.e. tort reform) Why if I'm rich should I hve to pay higher taxes to foot the bill for those who choose not the do it themselves and then have to go out and pay a private doctor. The US as a country wasn't built on everything is equal. You only are promised one thing. You work hard and you can make a great life here. That's why so many people immigrate to the US every year, because of that opprotunity, not because they are going to be given something.  Last, it's going to cost this country way maore than the trillion of $$$ that this country doesn't have anyways.



I do want to say also, that I mean no disrepect at all to either one of you.

Last edited by ShawnK (2010-04-06 19:48:05)

http://www.thebjjlifestyle.com/

11

Re: Obama's Health Care

Just a few things -

1. I'm from Europe, (UK) so to not have universal healthcare seems like something out of the dark ages for me? Our healthcare may not be the world's greatest, but I can go see a doctor about any problem I have for FREE, and so can anyone else who is legally in the UK.

2. To fully understand why so many Americans are against the Healthcare bill, it would be nice to know the reality of what the situation was beforehand. Say I'm a 24 y/o U.S Citizen, just lost my job due to no fault of my own and I find some problem (lets say a lump) that I feel needs to be looked at. I've got no insurance, I've probably not got much money, what would have been the procedure here? If the case is that I get no healthcare at all (all all the implications for me that comes with that) do you guys think that's acceptable?

3.  Sorry to bring this into it (especially seeing as my country CANNOT talk in this regard) http://costofwar.com/ - Would you rather see that money spent on Healthcare reform or in Iraq and Afghanistan. (Not sure how relevant it is, but the figures are both astronomical and I guess in that way comparable...)

4. What is everyone's ideal version of healthcare? Totally free market? Just interested.

Disclaimer: I'm a White Belt, ergo anything I say may be wrong!

Currently a student at Gracie Barra Leeds.
Still feel at home at Gracie Barra Draculino Team Marbella.

12

Re: Obama's Health Care

Sam,

currently, when an individual has no insurance, lost a job, etc... they go to the hospital and the government (the people) still pay for the services rendered... not much of a difference from how it will be when the "new" healthcare system begins... the people (government) will still pay for those without the means to pay for insurance...

13

Re: Obama's Health Care

in my opinion, as a citizen of a country, you have to take part for building up your country; and that's whith taxes.  i live in beglium, and we are one of the most taxed countries in the world.  but, that's the system, and as long as you can live well, then it is my pleasure to help other people.  and this has nothing to do with being a socialist country. i visited the united states, many years ago, and spoken with people about the taxes; believe me, the taxes that you have to pay are very very low. for responding what sam hall says, i understand perfectly his point. i don't want to start a political discussion here, because i don't want to offense anyone, but if a country can start a war in iraq(which by the way has nothing to do with the war against the war of terror) they can also improve the healthcare system.  the war will by the way also get payed by the citizen with taxes...
so guys, that's just a small overview of my opinion.  think like that, we are just bjj students who share our passion for a fantastic martial art, let us by be friends and exchange our opinions and be open minded for other ideas and respect each others.  take care of all of you and god bless

14

Re: Obama's Health Care

be careful talking about the US starting wars... as i recall, europe, asia and africa owe a debt of gratitude for the US getting into WWII when they had already lost all of their land, freedoms, etc. to the germans... hundreds of thousands of Americans died for your country and ours...

btw...if the war in iraq is so wrong and Obama is so great, why hasn't he pulled the troops out? why has he strengthened the efforts in afganistan? ...there must be more to what's really going on than what is being reported... because if Obama believed he could bring the troops home and there was no reason for them to be abroad, he would do it... .02

15

Re: Obama's Health Care

chewie; europe has been liberated in ww2 by a coalition americans, candians, british, north african, european soldiers, etc...
we will be eternally thankfull to those people ! but that doesn't mean, that we have to follow blindness nowadays its policy. everyone has his own opinion, you should respect that !!! concerning obama, no one here stated that he is so great; we just said , that he did a good move towards the healthcare system.
hope you understand little bit my point of view

16

Re: Obama's Health Care

I know America has been portrayed as an ugly war starting bully, but like chewie mentioned, you might want to look at all the things America has done for other countires. There are so many government programs already inplace to take care of the sick and elderly. If you are young with no insurance and have a medical problem you go to the hospital. Hospitals cannot refuse to treat you. There are also free clinics availible to you. Trust me, this health care bill has NOTHING to do with helping people. People think it will be FREE to go to a doctor. WRONG, someone is paying for it. Big problem is, this isn't to cover just the ones that don't have it. It will take the place of all other ins. WHY would a large company that provides low cost ins to it's employees ( high cost to them) now continue doing it if they can just stop and make you go with the government plan? Which will be much worse in terms of care. I know you guys in other countries like what you have, but that's because you have had nothing else  and are programmed to expect nothing more.

http://www.thebjjlifestyle.com/

17

Re: Obama's Health Care

i understand your point of view, however, those of us who currently pay for healthcare and are being taxed to pay for indigent care should have the final decision on how healthcare should be handled in the US. the new healthcare legislation that was passed doesn't fix the problems we have, nor does it get us any closer to proper healthcare coverage for the masses. basically the new plan will "cover" indigent individuals who currently can't pay for or afford to acquire healthcare. those same patients were already having the government...the people...pay for their healthcare... nothing has changed.

btw...the unprecidented vote that took place was manipulated under an obscure parlamentary procedure to force a vote that was not representative of our democracy... we'll see how things go... i appreciate your interest in our policies...

18

Re: Obama's Health Care

Shawnk, I see where youre comming from and I see our opinions will always differ on this matter. It's my opinion that the upperclass in general are far privileged and can really afford to help some less fortunate souls. Im from sweden which is a socialist country and because I know that the government will never let me starve or be homeless I feel I have the freedom to really pursue my dreams because I can afford to fail once, I will have more chances. Of course there is some problems with this as well but no system is perfect. And yes I am a socialist, don't confuse this with communism, that's very different.

But different opinions is the heart of democracy so cheers to disagreeing.

19

Re: Obama's Health Care

That's cool. We can agree to disagree.

http://www.thebjjlifestyle.com/

20

Re: Obama's Health Care

This country was built on people working hard for what they got. Like Shawn said, You work hard and you can make a great life here. That's why so many people immigrate to the US every year. In nature it is the strong that will survive, that's what keeps the species strong and the species will survive. In life we have to except our own realty or change it, if I want something I will go and get it and that will make me strong. Everyone knows a rich kid with daddy's money, if it does not come easy for them they quit, everything they got was on a silver platter. But I bet there Dad worked hard for it and is not like his kid.

BJJ is the Greatest Martial Art in the world and it takes hard work, dedication and years to get to a Black Belt. The  Black Belts in BJJ would not be near as good if it was easy. So our country should stay strong by giving out opportunities not freebies

There is a Free Heath Care System in this country that works, the county hospitals will not turn you away and you can get treatment. It is not a system that is easy, you have to learn it. But we don't have to pay 50% or more in taxes ether.

See you on the mat...

Captain

21

Re: Obama's Health Care

No offense to anyone, but I'm seeing a lot of misconceptions about the bill, so just to keep the debate healthy, I'm going to post some straight up facts about what this bill does:

- Your insurance company cannot drop your coverage if you get sick or injured.

- Your insurance company cannot put a cap on the amount of coverage they provide over your lifetime. If you get sick/injured, they have to keep covering after you've paid your part until you die. Health and Human Services is now empowered to restrict annual limits.

-Children cannot be denied coverage for a pre-existing condition.*

-Your parents can keep you on their health plan until you are 26.

-There are numerous tax credits available for small businesses that provide coverage.

-Indoor tanning services will have a 10% tax. Sorry ladies, your tanning sessions are going to get more expensive.

All of that is now law since Obama signed the bill last month.

Medicare will be overhauled in the next 7 years. I didn't read too much into those provisions because they really don't apply to me, but the major change to Medicare is the amount of prescription drug coverage is being greatly increased.

By 2014, web-accessible insurance exchanges will be established in every state. What is a health insurance exchange? It is a government-run marketplace where individuals go to buy private insurance plans. The private insurers must comply with government regulations. Basically, if you participate in an exchange, you shop for health insurance the same way you shop for utilities. Also, a national mandate that everyone must purchase healthcare will take effect. Failure to do so will result in a "fine". It's not really a fine, in the language of the bill it is written as a tax.

*There's been a lot of news articles saying that health insurance companies have found a loophole that allows them to deny coverage to children with pre-existing conditions. Why they even thought to look for one is beyond me, but I'm telling you right now it won't work. There is what a law says and what a law was intended to do. The executive branch will make sure that the intent of the law is followed.

22

Re: Obama's Health Care

captain,
here in europe , education and health is the same for everyone; whatever you are rich or poor.
it is just a basic way of life; afterwords when you grow up, it is your choice to do want you want to do with your life. if you don't work , you will live poor; and if you work hard with dedication you can also make it.
about the fact, that only the strong surive and having a strong specie ????
let us say, you are poor and you have some kids . one of them is very ill and needs medical treatmant; but you can not pay it. how would you feel ? also that the strong survive ?

23

Re: Obama's Health Care

amando wrote:

captain,
here in europe , education and health is the same for everyone; whatever you are rich or poor.
it is just a basic way of life; afterwords when you grow up, it is your choice to do want you want to do with your life. if you don't work , you will live poor; and if you work hard with dedication you can also make it.
about the fact, that only the strong surive and having a strong specie ????
let us say, you are poor and you have some kids . one of them is very ill and needs medical treatmant; but you can not pay it. how would you feel ? also that the strong survive ?

I am a single father, 5 or 6 years ago I had serious medical problem, with no insurance I was in between jobs. I was able to get help through our Free Health Care System that we now have in place, like I said it was a system that I had to learn how to use, its not perfect but it is available to everyone. So Amando I do know a little about this topic. In This country there is Free Health Care to the poor and to people out of work, people with money and a income will have a choice, to buy insurance or not. A simple plan that works, it's not perfect but it works.

We should learn the system that we now have, work out some of the problems or we can do the Obamacare thing and get taxed on at least 1/2 of our income, have our Social Security retirement & benefits go away (I only have 14 years to go and have payed into it all my life). And then louse our freedom and become a socialist country?

See you on the mat...

Captain

24

Re: Obama's Health Care

captain,
i have a question for you about the healthcare; i like to know and understand the things and hear it from an insider point of view; you talked that there is a free healthcare for the poor; and that the rich or working people can buy an insurance.
is the free healthcare of the same quality qua medical treatment ? if yes, i don't understand why the rich have to buy an extra insurance.
it would be nice to hear about it.
kind regards,
amando

ps; see me on the mat would be difficult, as i am from belgium wink

25

Re: Obama's Health Care

amando wrote:

captain,
i have a question for you about the healthcare; i like to know and understand the things and hear it from an insider point of view; you talked that there is a free healthcare for the poor; and that the rich or working people can buy an insurance.
is the free healthcare of the same quality qua medical treatment ? if yes, i don't understand why the rich have to buy an extra insurance.
it would be nice to hear about it.
kind regards,
amando

ps; see me on the mat would be difficult, as i am from belgium wink

I am not a insider, I am just am American that believes that the The Constitution of The United States
should not be changed. This country was founded on freedom and the insurance industry should stay privet. Every time the government gets involved things gets messed up.

I understand that 22 states are suing the government over Obamacare and it is said that more will follow. The majority of the people don't want it, but Obama is shoving it down our throats.


Our ancestors came to this country for freedom, now it is slowly going away....

http://www.drudgereport.com/ You may take a look at this link, they tell it like it is without bias

See you on the mat...

Captain